our logo

Monday, October 30, 2006

Would It Be Better For The World If The Republicans Won?

As the US Congressional elections loom, the pessimism I've been feeling about a Democratic win finds an echo in this comment at Gary Younge's US election piece in the Guardian today:

I personally hope the republicans win. None of the us political parties are interested in doing what is right, just what is most profitable for themselves and their rich sponsers. The only real difference is in levels of arrogance, the republicans don't care what the rest of the world thinks of their rapacious, world destroying greed and the democrats have enough intelligence to realise that playing their game a little more tactically makes it easier to do what ever they please. I think that for the good of this planet and its human population (of which the usa population makes up a measly 5%)we all see the usa for what it really is and the best people to demonstrate this is the immoral scum called the republican party. Let them take full responsbility for their global misadventures and selfish greedy policies.

You have to admit (s)he has a point - when you take a closer look at the people a Democratic vote will put in Congress, and consider where that party's major funding stream comes from, it slowly starts to sink in that even if they win by a landslide, a Dem victory will mean very little to us in the rest of the world.

Take Nancy Pelosi for instance, the self-described 'ultimate security mom', who'll likely be Speaker of the House, Diebold willing. Already she's said she won't push for impeachment for Bush.

And can anyone tell me where, if anywhere, she's committed herself to repealing any of draconian wingnut legislation like the Patriot Act? What about the Military Commissions Act, that overturned habeas corpus and which overides the US constitution, allowing a President to torture or disappear any individual, anywhere in the world, in flagrant defiance of every known international law?

Her words on this issue are as mealy-mouthed as it gets:

“Democrats voted overwhelmingly to go to war in Afghanistan so that those responsible for the 9/11 attacks would be brought to justice. More than five years later, because of the failure of the Bush Administration to devise a legal process that could withstand the scrutiny of the Supreme Court, not a single person who planned the attacks has been tried and convicted.

“That record of failure is unlikely to be improved by the military commissions bill President Bush signed today. Legal challenges to the bill may result in convictions being overturned, punishments being set aside, and justice being further delayed. In addition, because the bill allows the President to interpret the Geneva Conventions through executive order, it invites other countries to do the same, thereby weakening the international legal standards that have protected our troops for decades.

“Democrats want terrorists who kill Americans tried, convicted, and punished through a constitutionally sound process that will be upheld on appeal. That goal will not be achieved by the bill President Bush signed into law today.”

Do you see the word torture anywhere there? Where in that blob of pablum did she actually say anything about torture, or illegality, or unconstitutional power grabs? She may have implied it, but only very slightly and obliquely. That press release was the PR equivalent of spitting into a hurricane.

And speaking of which, what about global warming? Has she promised to even push the US' signing up to Kyoto ? Hell, no.

No, Pelosi supports the Safe Climate Act , a pathetic bandaid of a bill which relies on the free market to police itself and if passed would merely freeze US emissions at their current level. Well, woop-de-bloody-doo. Way to save the planet Democrats.

Those emissions levels got us to this point in the first place so keeping them the same is hardly progress. The Democrats and Pelosi act as though global warming is something way, way off in the future and that they can somehow preserve the current American way of life frozen in time, so all those industries whose PACs help fund their campaigns can blithely carry on polluting as before and no-one has to actually, you know, do anything or suffer at all.

And then there's the issue of Israel and and its lobbyists within the Democratic party. On that topic for Democrats the position is eyes closed, mouths shut, hands out. Ms Pelosi herself pledged the party's unwavering support and commitment to Israel even as they were bombing Lebanese civilians with white phosphorous, cluster bombs and worse.

I sure as hell don't want the Republicans to win but the Democrats are not exactly the cavalry coming to the rescue, as some American liberal bloggers seem to fervently believe. Even those aware of the paucity of Democratic positions are taking the Polly Toynbee voting stance - hold your nose and vote Dem anyway. Anything for a change.

As much as I'd like to see a woman in such a high political office as Speaker (and she seems perfectly competent to do the job) and glad as I am that at least the Democrats are mostly honest, I still can't forget that they're just as in hock to the corporations and the lobbyists as the Republicans are. Even the netroots types will become so, after a short spell inside the beltway. It's the whole system that's fucked.

Looked at from a non-USAnian perspective this election's really just a cosmetic exercise. Nothing will really change. The architects of the war, the PNAC types, the crooks, the war-profiteers, the torturers and all Bushco's other minions will walk away unscathed - because we can't have America's self-image besmirched publicly now, can we? The tortured themselves will likely be discreetly paid off, or dumped and ignored. and people will still be dying by their hundreds in Iraq every day. There is no automagically happy ending the day after the election.

One hopeful thought (though it's a bit of a faint hope, that I'm basing on the principle that it's always darkest before the dawn) is that if the Republicans win this time, according to the poll-numbers it'll likely have been by using nefarious means. There is so much pentup anxiety and anger about the government that has had no real outlet so far- and if the election is stolen again it may just be the spark that fires real reform in the US.

Emphasis on the may.

Digg this

Read more: US Politics, Congressional Election, Nancy Pelosi

|

| | | | | | | | |


Comments: Post a Comment

Home

"I think all foreigners should stop interfering in the internal affairs of Iraq."
-- U.S. Deputy Defense Secretary Paul Wolfowitz, 21 July 2003

Mail Prog Gold

Self promotion

Martin:
Wis[s]e Words
International (political) weblog.
Booklog

Republic of Palau:
Take it as Red

Progressive weblogs:

Descriptions underneath are as much as possible taken from the weblog itself.

Fun-loving Feministas

Carnival of the Feminists
Held on the first and third Wednesday of each month and aims to showcase the finest feminist posts from around the blogsphere.

Fetch Me My Axe
...we've all got something to grind. By Belledame222.

Pandagon
It's just Amanda now, strong on feminism.

Red State Feminist
Women's and Children's Issues, Family Law, Domestic Violence

Lefty lawyers

Lawyers, Guns and Money
No idea if they're really lawyers, actually

TalkLeft
The politics of crime.

Middle East knowitalls

Aron's Israel Peace weblog
short commentary on news items, articles and op-ed pieces about the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

Bethlehem bloggers
Voices from the Bethlehem ghetto.

Jews sans Frontieres
Mark Elf's anti-zionist blog.

Juan Cole
Required reading on Iraq and the Middle East.

Today in Iraq
What's really happening in Iraq

Soulfull scientists

Pharyngula
Science, politics and the intersection between them. By PZ Myers.

Science and Politics
Bora Zivkovic is trying to understand US politics by making strange connections between science, religion, brain, language and sex.

Thus Spake Zuska
Not very polite.

Steadfast socialists

Actually Existing
Ruthless criticism of all that exists, except for the good bits. By Phil Edwards.

American Leftist
'Intelligent discontent is the mainspring of civilization.' -- Eugene V. Debs

Apostate Windbag
A journal of assorted leftwingery with a decided preference for discussing how the late Christopher Hitchens is a twat

Bionic Octopus
"better...faster...coconutter."

Dead Men Left
Meaders is active in the RESPECT coalition, but don't hold it against him

GlobBlog
A blog about globalisation. By General Glut.

International Rooksbyism
Not just another scummie student commie's blog. By Ed Rooksby.

Law and Disorder
Socialism and the legal systems

Left I on the News
A leftwing view of the day's news and the way it's represented in the media. By Eli.

Lenin's Tomb
Erudite English Socialist Workers Party supporter.

A New Morning
German/English socialist leaning blog.

Perspective
by Alister Black, Scottish socialist. Writes mainly about local issues.

Sonic's Place
A computer generated, left-wing hedgehog's views on the world and the war

An Unenviable Situation
D Ghirlandaio on politics, art and the culture at large

Unrepentant Marxist
By Louis Proyect, veteran Marxist

Virtual Stoa
Home of the Dead Socialist Watch. By Chris Brooke.

They make fun of the right

So we don't have to.

Alicublog
Plays the stock market of the soul -- and sells short!

Go Fug Yourself
Mocking our betters in Hollywood and tv...

Jesus' General
An 11 on the Manly Scale of Absolute Gender

The Poor Man Institute
For Freedom, Democracy and a Pony.

Sadly No!
A group blog dedicated to make fun of idiots.

TBOGG
Faithful husband, soccer dad, basset owner, and Peggy Noonan stalker

World of Crap
Come point and laught at the fundies and rightwing loonies

Loveable liberals

American Samizdat
The collective effort of over thirty leftwing bloggers.

American Street
A collective of leftist bloggers, poisoning our precious bodily fluids.

Archy
politics, fringe watching, and other stuff. By John McKay.

The Burnt Orange Report
News, Politics, and Fun from Deep in the Heart of Texas.

Democratic Veteran
Because not every vet is a right winger or pseudo facist. By Jo.

Dependable Renegade
By watertiger, who has not yet shot anybody in the face ...yet.

Eschaton
The liberal answer to Instapundit?

FABlog
By David Ehrenstein

A Fistful of Euros
A groupblog focusing on the EU and European politics.

Hronkomatic
Paying good money to shut George Will up. By Jason McCullough.

Hullabaloo
Digby, frequent and eloquent commentor at various blogs finally has his own.

James Wolcott
Journalist, media personality and blogger

John Quiggin
Commentary on Australian & world politics from John Quiggin

Lean Left
by Kevin Raybould

The Left Coaster
Outside-the-Beltway perspectives on politics, current events, and the media

Left in the West
Written by Matt Singer, a Montanan who writes on local issues and national issues and how they correspond to Montana and the west.

Liberal Oasis
Where the left is right and the right is wrong.

Mad Kane's Noteables
commentary on and song parodies about politics, current events, books, music, and anything else that inspires her admiration or ire.

Majikthise
Analytic philosophy and liberal politics by Lindsay Beyerstein and others.

Making Light
Teresa and Patrick Nielsen Hayden's politics and life blog.

The Martini Republic
Group blog. Nice design, good content.

Mikhaela's News Blog
By Mikhaela Reid.

Musings and Migraines
Chicago liberal's musings on war, peace, Jon Stewart, art, media. By Lenora.

Nathan Newman
A community and union activist, policy advocate and writer with an excellent weblog.

Oliver Willis
Like kryptonite to stupid.

Orcinus
Policy, Culture and Journalism in the 21st Century. By David Neiwert.

Pacific Views
regime change begins at home, escalate nonviolence. By Natasha.

Polygon, the Dancing Bear
Occasional notes on politics, history, architecture, and life. By Lawrence Kestenbaum.

Prometheus 6
"What I want to do here is talk to the town criers. And I'll be talking more about people than politics."

Rittenhouse Review
A journal of foreign policy, finance, ethics, and culture. By James M. Capozzola

The Road to Surfdom
an intermittent weblog by Tim Dunlop.

Ruminate This
News, views, activism and a smattering of something else. By Lisa English.

Sasha Undercover
Observations and commentary on politics, women, culture, and daily life. Not for the faint of heart.

Seeing the Forest
...for the trees

Shadow of the Hegemon
Written by returned from the death Greek demagogue Demosthenes so is very eloquent.

The Sideshow
Avedon makes me think. Her weblog revolves around US politics.

Skimble
Culture, politics, commentary, criticism. Views from the left, headquartered in Chicago USA.

Slacktivist
Hopeful outrage, politics, culture and religion from a progressive Christian perspective.

Smythe's World
Politics, baseball and more.

Steve Gilliard's News Blog
Insightful (inciteful?) and interesting

This Modern World
By Tom Tomorrow

Thoughts on the Eve of the Apocalypse
By Bill Connolly

Through the Looking Glass
A chronicle of the absurd, in politics and life. By Charles Dodgson

Wampum
Progressive Politics, Indian Issues, and Autism Advocacy. By "MB".

Whiskey Bar
Free thinking in a dirty glass. By Daily Kos alumni Billmon.

Xoverboard
Blogging and cartoons! Whoot!

Progressive news

Alt.Muslim

AlterNet

Common Dreams

Consortium News

Counterpunch

Crooks and Liars

Electronic Intifada

Indymedia

information Clearing House

Left Turn Magazine

Narco News

The Raw Story

Socialist Worker UK

World Socialist Web Site

Working for Change

Ping

This page is powered by Blogger, the easy way to update your web site.

Listed on BlogShares